100+ Easter Basket Stuffer Ideas for Toddlers and Babies in 2025
Easter is right around the corner, which means it’s time to start planning the perfect Easter basket for your little one!
Whether you’re celebrating baby’s first Easter or looking for fun and engaging items for your growing toddler, creating a thoughtful basket can be both exciting and stress-free.
I love putting together Easter baskets for my kids. It’s one of my favorite traditions!
But instead of filling them with just candy and treats, I like to include fun, practical, and age-appropriate gifts that they can actually use and enjoy.
If you’re looking for Easter basket ideas for toddlers and babies, I’ve rounded up some of the best options to make this Easter extra special for your little one.
This post contains affiliate links for your convenience. For more information, see my disclosures here.
Choosing the Perfect Easter Basket
Before we get into the fun stuffers, let’s talk about the basket itself!
There are so many adorable options to choose from, whether you go with a traditional wicker basket, a personalized fabric tote, or even a functional storage bin that can be reused in your child’s nursery or playroom.
Pro Tip: I like to stick with neutral, reusable baskets so they can be used beyond Easter. Perfect for toy storage or books!
SHOP
Once you’ve chosen your basket, don’t forget to add some Easter grass as a filler. I prefer paper shred Easter grass over plastic because it’s more eco-friendly and easier to clean up.
SHOP
Easter Basket Stuffer Ideas for Toddlers
Toddlers are at such a fun and curious stage, so filling their Easter basket with interactive and engaging items is a great way to make the holiday even more special.
1. Easter-Themed Stuffed Animals
Every toddler loves a soft, snuggly friend! Choose a cute bunny, chick, or lamb that will make the perfect Easter cuddle buddy.
SHOP
2. Art Supplies & Crafts
Encourage creativity with art supplies that are toddler-friendly. Some fun options include:
SHOP
3. Easter Books for Toddlers
Books make wonderful Easter basket fillers! Look for spring or Easter-themed board books with interactive flaps or touch-and-feel elements to keep little ones engaged.
SHOP
4. Outdoor Toys Easter Basket Ideas
As the weather warms up, Easter is the perfect time to introduce new outdoor toys! Some fun ideas include:
SHOP
5. Bath Toys for Toddlers
Make bath time even more fun with some new bath goodies:
SHOP
6. Small Toys for Toddlers
Keep little hands busy with simple toys that encourage fine motor skills and creativity.
SHOP
7. Easter-Themed Clothes & Accessories
Easter is the perfect excuse to refresh your toddler’s spring wardrobe! Consider adding:
SHOP
Easter Basket Stuffer Ideas for Babies
If you’re celebrating baby’s first Easter, you’ll want to fill their basket with soft, safe, and sensory-friendly items.
1. Snuggly Easter Stuffed Animals
A plush bunny or lamb makes the perfect Easter keepsake for babies. Look for ones made of ultra-soft, baby-safe fabric.
SHOP
2. Easter Books for Babies
Introduce your little one to the joy of books with bright, engaging board books featuring simple words and textures.
SHOP
3. Bath Toys for Baby’s Easter Basket
Make bath time extra fun with:
SHOP
4. Developmental Baby Toys
For younger babies, include sensory toys that help with grasping and fine motor skills, such as:
SHOP
5. Easter Clothes and Accessories
Dress baby up for Easter Sunday with:
SHOP
6. Practical Baby Essentials
You can also add everyday baby must-haves that parents will appreciate:
SHOP
Related: Ultimate Baby Registry Checklist Printable
Non-Candy Easter Basket Ideas for Toddlers & Babies
If you’re looking to limit sugar this Easter, try adding these fun, non-candy alternatives to your little one’s basket:
✔️ Stickers or sticker books
✔️ Wooden puzzles
✔️ Musical shakers
✔️ Soft dolls or plush animals
✔️ Play scarves for sensory play
Final Thoughts on Easter Basket Stuffer Ideas for Toddlers & Babies
Easter baskets don’t have to be filled with candy to be exciting! Thoughtful, age-appropriate gifts make the holiday special while also encouraging creativity, learning, and fun.
Whether you’re shopping for a tiny baby or an energetic toddler, these Easter basket ideas will help you create a memorable, joy-filled holiday for your little one.
Happy Easter!
